WTC Memorial Finalists

I’ve studied architecture in years past and love reflecting over the new designs, that have been put on display, for both the new World Trade Center and the Memorial. Here are some brief thoughts on each of the 8 finalists for the Memorial Competition.

1. Votives in Suspension
   After initial review, this might be my favorite. Each light represents a life lost in this intimate, muted environment. The lights are suspended as if moving up, reminding us the human souls eternal significance.
2. Lower Waters
   I found this entry to be weak and unimaginative, neither address the magnitude of loss or giving us a message for the future.
3. Passages of Light: Memorial Cloud
   Another one of my favorites as the victim’s individuality is represented in a creative and appropriate way all exposed for all to see—iberating and victorious.
4. Suspending Memory
   Representing life lost with life living rings true to my ear. Simple concept but powerful still.
5. Garden of Lights
   Probably my least favorite, as it leads me to a Hollywood-conclusion which is hollow and most-often pointless. Technology overshadows.
6. Reflecting Absence
   Interesting concept but is better implemented in other submissions, as the cold style leaves little to inspire.
7. Dual Memory
   I believe the intent of these designers might be pure but the eventual perception might not enhance the memory of those who died as well as say, the Votives or Cloud concepts. It’s also leaves a bit of the sour taste of advertising.
8. Inversion of Light
   Another interesting concept that the single image doesn’t adequately communicate. Could be nice but I’m unsure.